← Back to WhereToFIRE Calculator

🇺🇸 United States vs 🇮🇹 Italy

Side-by-side early retirement comparison — taxes, cost of living, healthcare, and FIRE number.

Key Takeaway

Italy is significantly cheaper than United States for retirees. With a cost of living index of 65 vs 100, your money goes 35% further in Italy. Capital gains tax is 26% in Italy vs 0% in United States. Use the calculator to see your personalized FIRE number for both countries.

Side-by-Side Comparison

🇺🇸
United States
🇮🇹
Italy
Cost of Living
Overall Index
100
65
Rent (City)
$2,500/mo
$1,200/mo
Rent (Suburb)
$1,800/mo
$700/mo
Taxes
Capital Gains (LT)
0%
26%
Top Income Tax
37%
43%
Healthcare
Est. Annual Cost
$3,000
$0
Public Access
No
Yes
Other
Currency
$ USD
€ EUR

Tax Comparison for Retirees

🇺🇸 United States Taxes

$0–$11,92510%
$11,925–$48,47512%
$48,475–$103,35022%
$103,350–$197,30024%
$197,300–$250,52532%
$250,525–$626,35035%
$626,350+37%

🇮🇹 Italy Taxes

0–€28,00023%
28,000–€50,00035%
50,000+43%

Special Tax Regimes for Expats

🇮🇹

Flat Tax for Retirees

7% flat tax on ALL foreign income for retirees in Southern Italy/small towns.

10 years📋 Pensioners moving to municipalities <20k population in Southern regions.
🇮🇹

Impatriate Regime

70-90% income exemption for workers.

5-10 years📋 Not resident in Italy for 2+ years. Must work in Italy.

Calculate Your Exact FIRE Number

Enter your portfolio, spending, and retirement age to see a personalized comparison between United States and Italy — with Monte Carlo simulations and tax modeling.

🔥 Open Calculator — United States vs Italy

FAQ: United States vs Italy for Retirement

Is it cheaper to retire in Italy or United States?

Italy has a cost of living index of 65 compared to United States's 100(where US = 100). Italy is significantly cheaper than United States for retirees. Your money goes approximately 35% further in Italy.

How do taxes compare between United States and Italy?

Capital gains tax is 26% in Italy vs 0% in United States. The top income tax rate is 43% in Italy vs 37% in United States. For FIRE retirees, the effective tax rate depends on your withdrawal strategy — use our calculator for a personalized estimate.

What about healthcare in Italy vs United States?

Estimated annual healthcare costs are $0 in Italyvs $3,000 in United States. Italy offers public healthcare access for residents.

More Comparisons

More about retiring in United StatesMore about retiring in Italy